Tortorella has felt to keep his reasons quiet for benching Hayes however the evidence for this has been mounting for some time, especially for his defensive play. Torts is well known for his system of defense first and he is trying to send a message to Hayes to improve his defensive decisions.
Hayes has played in 31 games, has 9 goals and 20 assists for 29 points but is a glaring minus 12. That certainly sends alarm bells to the coach that he will be a defensive liability with the team trying to find their identity.