For the Penguins, finding the cap space to retain this star player is crucial. Guentzel has already scored 197 goals and earned 414 points in 453 NHL games. However, if he demands a higher salary, he could end up making more than the "Big 3," who have always taken team-friendly deals. Even Evgenii Malkin's salary was less than $9 million, with Sid the Adult earning $8.7 million against the cap and Kris Letang sitting at $7.8 million AAV.
Ultimately, it is up to Guentzel to determine his worth, but with Dubas in charge and Guentzel coming off a less productive year, it will be interesting to see how negotiations progress.