"Part of me understands why the Flyers have the stipulation to not include a player traded during the season. After all, they want to introduce the winner to the fans and make a big deal out of the presentation.
But isn't it more important to make the right choice?
Atkinson has had a good season, just not quite as good as Giroux, who was the Flyers' lone All-Star selection.
On merit," wrote Charchidi.